Dr. Javad T Hashmi @DrJavadTHashmi
PhD candidate in Religion at @Harvard; Physician, Ethicist, & Islamic Studies specialist youtube.com/@ImpactfulScho… Joined June 2020-
Tweets24K
-
Followers11K
-
Following1K
-
Likes13K
Unfortunately, @MohamadMurtaza_ completely misrepresents the field. Crone: If you really think Crone "brutally refuted" Schacht on his fundamental doubt about Ḥadīth as a source, then sigh, what can I say? Her views on this topic are well-known. Motzki's own words: “The…
@Abraham81891703 @HashUrTag @DrJavadTHashmi @khateeb88 I think that Donner has a similar view of Hadith to me: he is generally skeptical of Hadith and thinks that most are false or distorted, but also thinks that many contain authentic kernels or elements, which we can use. E.g., see Donner, Muhammad, p. 91:
The Challenge of Scholarship to the Quran x.com/i/broadcasts/1…
In the Qur'an, muslimin and mu'minin are NOT the same group. Likewise in Constitution of Medina. What @DrJavadTHashmi proposed in his debate with @DrShadeeElmasry is a good adaptation/tweak of Donner: mu'minin is those who have faith and submit to the Prophet in all respects;…
In the Qur'an, muslimin and mu'minin are NOT the same group. Likewise in Constitution of Medina. What @DrJavadTHashmi proposed in his debate with @DrShadeeElmasry is a good adaptation/tweak of Donner: mu'minin is those who have faith and submit to the Prophet in all respects;…
Crone Accepted Believers Thesis? Both Crone & Donner exchanged contentious words, but later seemed to display a lot of respect towards each other. Crone herself came around to espousing a view that sounds strikingly similar to Donner's own Believers thesis, writing: “It is…
Crone Accepted Believers Thesis? Both Crone & Donner exchanged contentious words, but later seemed to display a lot of respect towards each other. Crone herself came around to espousing a view that sounds strikingly similar to Donner's own Believers thesis, writing: “It is…
Thank you for having me on, @InspiringPhilos. I appreciate your time. It was a great conversation. [Q 29:46] And dispute not with the People of the Book, save in the most gracious manner, unless it be those of them who have done wrong. And say, “We believe in that which was…
Thank you for having me on, @InspiringPhilos. I appreciate your time. It was a great conversation. [Q 29:46] And dispute not with the People of the Book, save in the most gracious manner, unless it be those of them who have done wrong. And say, “We believe in that which was…
About to go live with @InspiringPhilos soon in order to promote our course with @BartEhrman. Come check it out: youtube.com/watch?v=K_cd1Z…
Historians consider this story to be fictional. There is also debate about whether the name is an endonym or exonym, the former indicating that they "withdrew" from the political fitna between competing factions.
Historians consider this story to be fictional. There is also debate about whether the name is an endonym or exonym, the former indicating that they "withdrew" from the political fitna between competing factions.
Ghazālī famously Takfīred Ibn Sīnā and Fārābī. There is no denying this fact. One can argue that later in his life, he became much closer to Islamic philosophy and mysticism, but early in his career, he was undoubtedly extreme with his views.
My next book is coming out on Sep 10: "The Islamic Moses: How the Prophet Inspired Jews and Muslims to Flourish Together and Change the World" (@StMartinsPress) And now, for just 3 days, Barnes & Noble (@BNBuzz) offers a chance for preorder with 25% off: bit.ly/3Ulkl5n
In this groundbreaking course led by Dr. Ehrman and Dr. Hashmi, explore the historical challenges inherent in two of the world's most influential religious texts—the Bible and the Quran. LAST CHANCE for EARLY-BIRD PRICING - it ends on April 21st! - bartehrman.com/holybookscourse
@DrJavadTHashmi @BartEhrman I wrote a bit about this here bliis.org/essay/muhammad…
Shaykh @YasirQadhi for me. Whether in agreement or in opposition, he has had an outsized effect on me.
Khalil Andani, PhD @KhalilAndani
18K Followers 8K Following Assistant Professor of Religion; PhD Islamic Studies @Harvard | Quranic Studies | Islamic Intellectual History: Kalam, Islamic Neoplatonism | Ismailism | CA-CPA
Mustafa Akyol @AkyolinEnglish
56K Followers 3K Following Senior Fellow on Islam and modernity at @CatoInstitute. Senior Lecturer at @BostonCollege. Author of a few books. Writes also in 🇹🇷 as @AkyolMustafa.
Marijn van Putten @PhDniX
29K Followers 842 Following Historical Linguist; Working on Quranic Arabic and the linguistic history of Arabic and Tamazight. Game designer @team18k
GabrielSaidR @GabrielSaidR
17K Followers 937 Following Crowley Prof. of Islamic Studies & Theology, Notre Dame. Youtube: "Exploring the Qur'an & the Bible." Author: "Allah: God in the Qur'an." Father of 5. Sinner.
Brethren of Purity @brethrenfpurity
4K Followers 299 Following Spreading rational philosophical Islam - Philosophy | Islam | Mysticism | Anti-Neo-Athari YouTube: https://t.co/JbQvdkmPd8
Joseph Lumbard, شا�.. @JosephLumbard
19K Followers 412 Following Associate Professor of Quran Studies, HBKU. Islam, Quran & Ecotheology. Subversive Academic. RT = contract sealed in blood. Devoted father, besotted husband.
Ahab Bdaiwi איהא�.. @abhistoria
32K Followers 941 Following Early Islam & Late Antiquity| Medieval Philosophy & Theology| Medieval Shiʿism| Manuscripts| Assistant Professor in Islamic Thought and History @UniLeidenNews
Joshua Little @islami.. @IslamicOrigins
6K Followers 205 Following ❝Jim❞ | Historian | Islamic origins, Hadith, textual criticism | DPhil in Asian & Middle Eastern Studies @UniOfOxford | anti-imperialism, anti-Islamophobia
khalid yousef @khalidsyossef
21K Followers 1K Following Manuscript studies, Mamluk, Islamic Art and Architecture, Byzantine, Medieval Mediterranean, Sufism, Turkish and Persian studies, Islamic Intellectual History
Sohaib Saeed د. صه.. @tafsirdoctor
27K Followers 1K Following Scottish Azhari. Purveyor of ḍād jokes and Great Exegesis. Director @IbnAshurCentre
Classy Arabic Poetry @ClassyArabic
18K Followers 885 Following Arabic poetry translations by Nathaniel Miller PhD Arabic Lit ex-Cambridge University, ex-NYU Pre-order The Emergence of Arabic Poetry 👇out August '24
Ustādh Ijaz @IjazTheTrini
43K Followers 429 Following Islāmic speaker, debater, & researcher. RT ≠ endorsement. • https://t.co/dQOsEBbbix • #i3 #EFDawah #MDI #ChronicallyIll ♿ #Trini 🇹🇹🍁
Asad أسد 🗽🍎 @AsadFromNYC
26K Followers 5K Following Local NYC historian and aspiring creative. Subscribe to my Substack to get updates on my walking tour company and storytelling project (TBA)!
Esmé Partridge @EsmeLKPartridge
13K Followers 1K Following 23. MPhil Philosophy of Religion at @Cambridge_Uni. Words in @TheCriticMag, @FirstThingsMag, @UnHerd and others
Mr. Terron Poole @Terodotus
2K Followers 1K Following Non-Denom Muslim لا إله إلا الله 510 Bay Area, California Native 🌉🧑💻🏖 Sképsislamica ✗ Real Talk We ❤️ MCR 🐝 🎸🏙️
Momodou ✊🏿 @MomodouTaal
20K Followers 1K Following PhDing: Political Economy, Race & Capitalism, Pan Africanism | The Malcolm Effect Podcast | IG: TheGambian 🇬🇲
شرقزده sharg.. @sharghzadeh
21K Followers 589 Following ‘sharq-zada’: struck by the east Teaching, translating Rumi @persianpoetics PRE-ORDER MY BOOK: https://t.co/iscFKo7rIN
Arsalan Khan @akkhan81
12K Followers 1K Following Political Anthropologist. Focus on Pakistan. My book: https://t.co/S1hdVMVt6r
Henry Azer @henry_azer
3 Followers 45 Following
Ganesh chandra kalada.. @GaneshKaladaran
78 Followers 1K Following
Rezaul Tanvir Tuhin @RezaulTTuhin
14 Followers 477 Following Co-founder and Chief Design Officer at Anun
AbdullahiAAM @Abdullahi_AAM
5 Followers 102 Following
Huzaifa Tahir @HuzaifaTah77810
1 Followers 78 Following
Syed Atif Rizwan, PhD @AbuJibreel6
2 Followers 64 Following Asst. Prof. Islamic and Interreligious Studies
John Lavender @TVJohnLavender
45 Followers 26 Following
Omar Baba @BabaOb91468
0 Followers 54 Following
Sean Mc Esq. @ResistanceSean
6K Followers 4K Following #Attorney #STEELERS #lakers Gemini 6/3. Oculus: Askia1 IG: SeanMcEsq
Mehmet Ferhat İlhan @mhmtferhatt
129 Followers 180 Following
Yu Smalls @LilYuyu1019
1 Followers 12 Following
Anonymousblue @Anonymousblue17
60 Followers 206 Following
Ibn Adam @IbneAdam_26
0 Followers 26 Following
Ozarr @Mavo340
0 Followers 39 Following
Miran ميران @mirUII8
0 Followers 54 Following
| Yousuf | @Ibnemaryam_
235 Followers 153 Following Love to talk about my life experiences | Travelling | Happiness | Understanding Quran 🌟| Music 🎼 | Follow me on Instagram, #Ibnemaryam_
epoche @mithradates70
1 Followers 55 Following
Arman @almaty_arman
52 Followers 144 Following
Hugo @HugoCbus
119 Followers 703 Following I read tweets and sometimes I comment. That's it that's my life. History, politics, science, and astronomy. 🔭 Dob 8" on eq. platform
Freshoredr @freshoredr38977
1 Followers 56 Following
hayan🍉حيَّان.. @Hayanomie
3K Followers 2K Following Learn about Syria from Syrians: Join the Discord & subscribe on YouTube 👇
brsduke @BrajaUSA
0 Followers 34 Following Interests: philosophy, science, religion. Analytical idealism, evolution and big bang, Indo-European origins, religious historicity.
suha @lxvespearbbae
30 Followers 107 Following
John Alcantara 🇵�.. @blackjamaican01
320 Followers 1K Following Rutgers University ‘19 | Stevens '20 | "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles"
Nick @NickMcKenzie5
1 Followers 11 Following
Al-Ma'arri @SBatttikh83310
4 Followers 80 Following إن الشرائع ألقت بيننا إحنا وأودعتنا أفانين العداوات
Enrique M San Vicente @CEnjunque
206 Followers 2K Following Cultural anthropologists / Consultor / Freelance researcher «Teórico De todo Militante De nada»
Abdillahi @Abdillahi_Osma
6 Followers 34 Following
Jordan Callaghan @JordanCala81346
32 Followers 239 Following
السلام @meme_hlal
3K Followers 657 Following ☪️ Théologie & histoire | “Elève tes mots, pas ta voix. C'est la pluie qui fait grandir les fleurs, pas le tonnerre.” (Djalâl ad-Dîn Rûmî)
Abdullah Al Mamun Som.. @SomratBinAftab
1 Followers 175 Following Hedonist yet a believer who works to lead a peaceful life with his direct & indirect dependants!
Genesis Eririoma @Apostle_Gen
98 Followers 165 Following An Apostle of Christ (Knowledge) to the nations.
Petr Hoffmann @PHoffmann_X
1 Followers 110 Following
Zakir Hussain @zakirhusain68
594 Followers 7K Following
Irum Fatima @IrumFatima68239
42 Followers 121 Following
Tanzil Shafique @TanzilShafique
2K Followers 3K Following A/Prof, Director of Sheffield Arch Grad school / Decolonial Cities Collective / Southern Theorising Group (STingG) / ন্যায্য আবাসন মঞ্চ / BD Climate Alliance
Khalil Andani, PhD @KhalilAndani
18K Followers 8K Following Assistant Professor of Religion; PhD Islamic Studies @Harvard | Quranic Studies | Islamic Intellectual History: Kalam, Islamic Neoplatonism | Ismailism | CA-CPA
Mustafa Akyol @AkyolinEnglish
56K Followers 3K Following Senior Fellow on Islam and modernity at @CatoInstitute. Senior Lecturer at @BostonCollege. Author of a few books. Writes also in 🇹🇷 as @AkyolMustafa.
Jonathan AC Brown @JonathanACBrown
63K Followers 667 Following Professor of Islamic Civilization @ Georgetown University, SFS, @ACMCU; https://t.co/LjFlkNt4jD
Marijn van Putten @PhDniX
29K Followers 842 Following Historical Linguist; Working on Quranic Arabic and the linguistic history of Arabic and Tamazight. Game designer @team18k
GabrielSaidR @GabrielSaidR
17K Followers 937 Following Crowley Prof. of Islamic Studies & Theology, Notre Dame. Youtube: "Exploring the Qur'an & the Bible." Author: "Allah: God in the Qur'an." Father of 5. Sinner.
Sean W. Anthony @shahanSean
23K Followers 932 Following Professor, historian, specialist in Mashriqī Studies at 𝕿𝖍𝖊 @OhioState University
Brethren of Purity @brethrenfpurity
4K Followers 299 Following Spreading rational philosophical Islam - Philosophy | Islam | Mysticism | Anti-Neo-Athari YouTube: https://t.co/JbQvdkmPd8
Joseph Lumbard, شا�.. @JosephLumbard
19K Followers 412 Following Associate Professor of Quran Studies, HBKU. Islam, Quran & Ecotheology. Subversive Academic. RT = contract sealed in blood. Devoted father, besotted husband.
Ahab Bdaiwi איהא�.. @abhistoria
32K Followers 941 Following Early Islam & Late Antiquity| Medieval Philosophy & Theology| Medieval Shiʿism| Manuscripts| Assistant Professor in Islamic Thought and History @UniLeidenNews
Joshua Little @islami.. @IslamicOrigins
6K Followers 205 Following ❝Jim❞ | Historian | Islamic origins, Hadith, textual criticism | DPhil in Asian & Middle Eastern Studies @UniOfOxford | anti-imperialism, anti-Islamophobia
Dr. Shadee Elmasry @DrShadeeElmasry
79K Followers 858 Following New blog posts on https://t.co/NUnmtDSsvB
Sohaib Saeed د. صه.. @tafsirdoctor
27K Followers 1K Following Scottish Azhari. Purveyor of ḍād jokes and Great Exegesis. Director @IbnAshurCentre
Protect our faith @ProtectYoFaith
4K Followers 353 Following Tired of beating around the bush. Muslim women, hold onto your faith. Allah created us, He knows us best and He is Just.
Dr. Éléonore Cellar.. @CellardEleonore
33K Followers 333 Following Researcher in early Qur'ānic manuscripts. Shaolin Kungfu in my free time
Classy Arabic Poetry @ClassyArabic
18K Followers 885 Following Arabic poetry translations by Nathaniel Miller PhD Arabic Lit ex-Cambridge University, ex-NYU Pre-order The Emergence of Arabic Poetry 👇out August '24
Caner Dagli 📿 soon.. @CKDagli
5K Followers 221 Following Books: The Study Quran / Metaphysical Institutions: Islam & the Modern Project / Ibn al-ʿArabī & Islamic Intellectual Culture / The Ringstones of Wisdom
Ustādh Ijaz @IjazTheTrini
43K Followers 429 Following Islāmic speaker, debater, & researcher. RT ≠ endorsement. • https://t.co/dQOsEBbbix • #i3 #EFDawah #MDI #ChronicallyIll ♿ #Trini 🇹🇹🍁
Asad أسد 🗽🍎 @AsadFromNYC
26K Followers 5K Following Local NYC historian and aspiring creative. Subscribe to my Substack to get updates on my walking tour company and storytelling project (TBA)!
Aitzaz Hussain Mayo �.. @aitzaz_mayo
15K Followers 552 Following Civil Servant |Ex Cop| Old Ravian|Humanity & Marxism|Progressive Poetry | Views are personal and for academic debate only| DM for Live Essay Evaluation on Zoom.
Sumaira Nawaz @NaTurkNaHindu
229 Followers 501 Following PhD Candidate, Institute of Islamic Studies, @mcgillu Researching literary traffics b/w Urdu, Turkish, Persian Embroidery enthusiast
STRATEGIC COUNCIL @Strategic_PAK
90 Followers 170 Following An independent GeoPolitical, GeoEconomics, Governance and IR Strategy think tank, advocating Progressive Pakistan.
Ali Khan @alikhanvirk
2K Followers 4K Following Lawyer | Juris Doctor candidate - @Griffith_Uni | Likes, retweets, and follows are not necessarily endorsements.
Murat Sincan @msincan
396 Followers 2K Following MD, FAMIA. Biomedical Informatician, Health Informatics Director @Flatiron , fmr @nih, Asst. prof @usd SSOM. Views my own, RT not endorsement.
Zakir Hussain @ZakirHussainMDI
10K Followers 2K Following Muslim Debater and Researcher with a special interest in Judaism and Christianity
Zeteo @zeteo_news
48K Followers 1 Following Unfiltered news. Bold opinions. A new media organization from @mehdirhasan.
Dr. Ruchika Sharma @tishasaroyan
31K Followers 407 Following History PhD @ JNU. I blend my two loves: eyemakeup and history at Eyeshadow & Etihaas. For enquiries/collabs contact [email protected]
David Cronin @dvcronin
11K Followers 4K Following Associate editor of The Electronic Intifada. Latest book ‘Balfour's Shadow: A Century of British Support for Zionism and Israel’
Mr. Bilal Muhammad @BilalsBoulder
523 Followers 168 Following just a geek - teacher, books: https://t.co/lETwni9W37 magazine: https://t.co/6ggGL6cc8B
John Mc Loughlin @jpmcl
2K Followers 5K Following #London via @UniOfHull Centre for #Philanthropy @UniKent, @GPhilanthropic, KCL LSE,@tcddublin.Soc capital #friendship #history #fundraising. Personal.
Alon Mizrahi I withou.. @alon_mizrahi
56K Followers 3K Following Antiestablishment, pro-humanity thinker, writer, and public speaker out of Israel. Abdalla's grandson. Support my work here https://t.co/unKjgHIxOI
Eli Kittim @Eli_of_Kittim
3K Followers 2K Following Bible Researcher | MA @NSSRNews | Grad @kinstitute | John W Rawlings School of Divinity | Journal of Higher Criticism | Goodreads Author | From Athens, Greece |
Int Peace Q Institute.. @IPQI_WDC
720 Followers 2K Following Advocating since 1985 a 21st century a peace, freedom, justice vision for societal transformation via inter-cultural/faith research education & collaboration
HadithCritic @HadithCritic
408 Followers 28 Following https://t.co/NysV35Dj39 Join the discord: https://t.co/RftpzA0PdP https://t.co/OXmS1XMmOD
Ali Ataie @UstadhAliAtaie
550 Followers 4 Following
Filip Almansour Holm @FilipHolm9
6K Followers 407 Following I make/play music. I study religion(s). I make videos about religion(s). I eat falafel.
Abdullah al Andalusi .. @AA_andalusi
1K Followers 1 Following 2nd account (because twitter shadow banned my main one: @abdullaandalusi)
GnosticQuran @GnosticQuran
290 Followers 90 Following Substance dualism theist / Islamic origins hobbyist YouTube: https://t.co/833SGFeqGa
Amar Mustafa | اما.. @Amarmustafa_
6K Followers 5K Following MENA women's history ig: @banatarchive | I research MENA working class and Arab Left history | current MA student in IR | own views, RT & likes ≠ Endorsement
Al-Mahdi Institute @AMIOutreach
2K Followers 92 Following Al-Mahdi Institute (AMI) provides an open platform for critical Muslim scholarship.
History Speaks @History__Speaks
6K Followers 254 Following Exposing muddle-headed history. YouTube: https://t.co/9yUcHxFID5 Substack: https://t.co/j6ZmPah0Qi Rumble: https://t.co/r9Mg1PF493
Roy @royllovians
2K Followers 840 Following Atomized millennial • Class reductionist • Homosexual male • Abolish plastic • Carceral urbanism
ssarah @bluemoongirl_2
11 Followers 56 Following
chonkshonk @chonkshonk1
428 Followers 55 Following Join r/AcademicQuran to discuss Qur'anic & Islamic studies from an academic perspective!
Ambassador Majed Bamy.. @majedbamya
41K Followers 2K Following Deputy Permanent Observer of the State of Palestine to the UN, New York. Palestinian from Yaffa. Refugee. The time for freedom is always right now!
MerryFleur_0 @Merry_Fleurx
493 Followers 140 Following like poetry and history, block doesnt mean dislike
Abdallah Nabeel Rashi.. @NabeelRashid108
328 Followers 1K Following Al-Quraniyya. Zen. Liberation. Seek not the path of the ancients; Seek that which the ancients sought. - Matsuo Basho
Plato's Stepchild @MattRob78281471
719 Followers 464 Following I'm the Prodigal returning home to Plato's Academy. The Quadrivium is philosophy and it's Catholic Philosophy in the truest sense.
Helen De Cruz @Helenreflects
37K Followers 10K Following Philosopher writing on science, religion, SFF, @SFWA, Codex, lute videos, Wonderstruck forthc. w @PrincetonUP https://t.co/D09RfzT6dl Any pronouns
Fauzia Husain فوز�.. @FauziaHusain
1K Followers 1K Following Sociologist @queensusoc. Author, The Stigma Matrix, SUP. she/hers 🇨🇦 🇵🇰. Wish I was writing right now 🙃
Patrick ₿ Dugan _ _.. @duganist
9K Followers 6K Following No hay futuro sin libertad. Founded @tradelayer: p2p derivatives for Bitcoin and Litecoin Building up treasures in the heavens (insha'Allah 🕌)
¡Viva la Revolución.. @shak007757
204 Followers 294 Following The Prophets, their companions, the great Muslim leaders, thinkers, emperors, researchers are my ideals. Peace upon them. And may Allah bless Imran Khan! Ameen!
roman lopez @romanlopezwa
14 Followers 32 Following
Rumaysa @rumaysah_
2K Followers 275 Following Islamic Ed/ Fiqh &Tafseer teacher/ Author/ Faith & Femininity bookclub/ I run the Female scholars network(Instagram)/ Member of Shariah council/ Science teacher
Yusuf Tayara يوسف.. @YusufTayara
712 Followers 1K Following DPhil in History of Science | MamlukAstronomy | Mediaeval and Early Modern Intellectual History @OxfordHistory Free Palestine. Views my own.
The "Kind" Servant @Nooberly
319 Followers 605 Following Live amongst people in such a way that when you are alive they crave for your company and when you die, they weep over you-Imam Ali A.S.
Safaitic Blog @SafaiticBlog
677 Followers 54 Following This Twitter account announces new posts on the Safaitic blog : https://t.co/ApWf71WX4N
☀️👀 @zei_squirrel
242K Followers 0 Following https://t.co/NbtDw6O4K1 | https://t.co/KKP8K845AV | [email protected] | Content that would get me banned here: https://t.co/wljPw2lIp9
Patrick Bet-David @patrickbetdavid
979K Followers 429 Following Yankees Minority Owner ⚾️ Author of “Your Next Five Moves” 📚 Born in Iran, Made In 🇺🇸 Half 🇦🇲 Half Assyrian 🎙️ PBD Podcast & Valuetainment
Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib @afalkhatib
40K Followers 1K Following Proud American from Gaza City; pro-Palestine, pro-peace, anti-Hamas; lost 31 family members in the war; Nonresident Senior Fellow @ACMideast; views are my own
Corpus Coranicum @CorpusCoranicum
1K Followers 148 Following Research department Corpus Coranicum, Berlin-Brandenburg Academy of Sciences. Focused on Qur’ānic manuscripts and studying the history of the Qur’ān.
Iyas Suleiman @IyasSulaiman
82 Followers 428 Following Quranic Studies - Islamic Theology - Muslim Intellectual Tradition - Classical Literature@MohamadMurtaza_ Your basis for 'until 1930s till 1950s' academics didn't think Muslims had a rational tradition is a hand-picked, unattributed quote about an art historian Ive not heard of until now (Schraeder) who, according to a quick search, didn't even do Islamic studies?
@Abraham81891703 @HashUrTag @DrJavadTHashmi @khateeb88 I think that Donner has a similar view of Hadith to me: he is generally skeptical of Hadith and thinks that most are false or distorted, but also thinks that many contain authentic kernels or elements, which we can use. E.g., see Donner, Muhammad, p. 91:
@InspiringPhilos @DrJavadTHashmi I'm attending his lecture series with @BartEhrman in two weeks.
@HashUrTag @_niaz__ @Abraham81891703 @DrJavadTHashmi @khateeb88 Niaz has just pointed out that your inference here was invalid. You should concede that. x.com/hashurtag/stat…
@_niaz__ @Abraham81891703 @DrJavadTHashmi @IslamicOrigins @khateeb88 So then all Ahadith have to be true since none of the narrators had any motives to diss Rasulullah ﷺ, no? That’s not how you grade the validity of a claim. It’s funny how you guys will just reject or accept claims based just on how palatable it is to you. 🤡
@HashUrTag @Abraham81891703 @DrJavadTHashmi @IslamicOrigins @khateeb88 Basics of logic: A true implies B false does not mean A false implies B true. And discounting hypocrites in Muhammad's midst, there were several motives for Hadith forgery: political / sectarian conflicts, legal / theological debates, racism and chauvinisms, story-telling etc.
@Abraham81891703 @HashUrTag @DrJavadTHashmi @IslamicOrigins @khateeb88 Check the isnad. Was it transmitted by people whose motive is to diss Donner? Then the reliability is in question. We can't just take this Hadith at face value and assume Donner really made such claims.
Throughout history, protests were co-opted and made to look bad so police and public leaders would shut them down. That’s what we are seeing now at Columbia University. The Columbia protesters have made clear their demands and want their school not to be complacent in the ongoing…
@Archetypical20 @DrJavadTHashmi @AbdalQaim Plenty of people are predisposed to the opposite thesis and the thesis itself. This is really irrelevant though.
@Archetypical20 @DrJavadTHashmi But one can be religiously pluralist without accepting the Donner thesis or any variation thereof. You are positing a causal relationship here that doesn’t necessarily exist.
@DrJavadTHashmi @Archetypical20 Sorry but suggesting that Khalil’s views on this are related to his religious proclivities is simply false. He’s certainly not echoing a Nizari Ismaili view on this subject. Rightly or wrongly, this is a conclusion he came to on his own and it IS an academic opinion.
The Challenge of Scholarship to the Quran x.com/i/broadcasts/1…
@Archetypical20 What are you talking about? How is my statement NOT academic? It is based on a well established academic theisis.
@DrJavadTHashmi @KhalilAndani @DrShadeeElmasry The appendix in Sinai's article "The Unknown Known" (2015/16) has a good discussion.
Tucker derangement syndrome is real. “It always appeared to us that, atomic bomb or no atomic bomb, the Japanese were already on the verge of collapse." -General Henry H. Arnold Commanding General of the U.S. Army Air Forces Under President Truman "Japan was at the moment…
Will also add here some Christian historical facts: In Nagasaki, the bomb was dropped 300 yards from a Catholic Church— Urakami cathedral. Nagasaki was the epicenter of Japanese Catholicism, home to the second largest cathedral in the East. Church was in session when the bomb…
@Rurouni_Phoenix @InspiringPhilos I just watched it, it was a good discussion
It should cost money to send an email and if you send too many they put you in jail
Nazi germany went even harder at students, executing them for their criticism of the Holocaust. The scare tactics & mass harassment of the militant Zionist empire will also be history soon. I am glad the #FreePalestine student movement is only gaining strength by the day. 🇵🇸
My colleague, @IslamicOrigins , recently published a very interesting and beautifully written article to study the hadiths on the origins of the art of Arabic writing.
A new article of mine was recently published by the Journal of Islamic Studies: "‘Where did you learn to write Arabic?’: A Critical Analysis of Some Ḥadīths on the Origins and Spread of the Arabic Script"
Got some big announcements to make hopefully in the next few days. Stay tuned.
Trends for United States
You might like
