פּעפּעלע @usershem

Pareto-optimal nationalist עולם העשיה Joined September 2017

Tweets

1K
Followers

105
Following

1K
Likes

4K

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 Yes

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 Then why do you throw at me sources that don’t claim that Ashkenazim are khazars when I say that Ashkenazim are not khazars?

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

@blackseraphim2 I think you are arguing against the argument you want me to be making rather than the one I actually am. Khazaria was real and Ashkenazi Jews have Khazar and other admixture. But admixture does not equal origin. And to say that Ashkenazim are khazars is incorrect.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 Earlier in the article the explanation offered by the researchers is that the Jewish and non-Jewish (Arabian) have a common ancestor. Other factors such as mutation rates come into effect. Also article shows hat Jewish alleles occurs at higher rates among Jews.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 I did follow up. My argument is that if there was a Jewish kingdom with a Jewish population there would be much more evidence of Jewish life. There is not, certainly not in comparison to Israel or other place where Jews lived in late numbers.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 “Probably” “can’t exclude” what about the other 48% percent? Also this is not about the Cohen haplotype.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 Unconvincing. A few coins, especially ones that might have been coined by Muslims, is not evidence of mass conversion. Europe and the Middle East are full of Jewish cemeteries, synagogues and other evidence of Jewish life.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 You don’t know what my beliefs are. All you know is that I pointed out holes in your theory.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 Turkic speakers move west adopt Slavic of surrounding population but then all of the sudden switch out 3/4 of their lexicon to German which is not the language of the surrounding Slavic population? And they don’t even retain any Turkic influence? Not very convincing.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 But more importantly, deconstructing identity is the type of sophistry engaged in by postmodernist social justice freaks, and is bullshit.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 This has nothing to do with the holes you can’t address in the Khazar theory. Try to stay on topic.

1 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 I can play this game too. Just go ahead and stop ignoring the holes in your theory.

0 0 0 0 0

View Details

פּעפּעלע @usershem

8 years ago

@blackseraphim2 There are groups of Jews who are known to descend from converts and they don’t have a Kohen lineage. Ashkenazim have a Kohen lineage, not just culturally but genetically. That, in addition to Yiddish and archeology, are huge holes in the Khazar theory. You have not filled them.