The CEO of Take-Two, the company behind GTA, just said something the entire AI industry doesn't want to hear.
And he said it without being anti-AI.
Strauss Zelnick's argument is precise. AI is built on datasets. Datasets are backward-looking. Creativity is forward-looking. A model trained on everything that already exists cannot, by definition, produce something genuinely unexpected. And all hits, by their very nature, are unexpected.
Asset creation and hit creation are not the same thing. AI is getting very good at the first one. The second one is what actually makes money, builds franchises, and changes culture. Nobody has shown AI can do that yet.
The derivative property problem is real. You can clone GTA with existing technology. You could do it before AI. It would take 3 years and look identical. It still wouldn't sell. Because it isn't GTA. It's a clone of GTA.
And consumers, despite what the industry occasionally pretends, can feel the difference between something genuinely new and something assembled from the residue of things that already worked.
Thousands of mobile games ship every year. 0 to 5 hits get made. The same studios make them every time. The technology to make more games has been commoditized for years. It didn't democratize hit creation. It just flooded the market with more forgettable product.
The Silicon Valley thesis that AI unlocks game creation for everyone is true in the same way that cheap cameras unlocked filmmaking for everyone. They did. And the same 5 studios still make the movies everyone watches.
What Zelnick is saying, without quite saying it, is that the thing AI cannot replicate is taste. The instinct for what hasn't been done yet. The cultural antenna that detects the gap in the market before the data can see it.
Data tells you what people wanted. Hits tell people what they want next.
Those are different jobs.
🇺🇸 Tucker lays out the deepest critique of AI yet, and it's not about jobs...
His argument: writing produces thinking.
You can't formulate a thought without first articulating it.
If kids never write because AI writes for them, the quality of human thinking collapses.
You have no experience.
You’ve never started a company.
You’ve never had a full time job.
Nike is going to kill you.
You’re a kid.
You don’t have technical skills.
You shouldn’t build hardware.
Apple is going to kill you.
You can’t build hardware.
You can’t measure heart rate non-invasively.
Athletes don’t care about recovery.
Under Armour is going to kill you.
It won’t be accurate.
You don’t listen.
You’re an ineffective leader.
You can’t recruit great talent.
You’re going to have to pay every athlete.
You can’t measure sleep non-invasively.
It’s too expensive to research.
Athletes are a small market.
The product costs too much to make.
The product costs too much to sell.
Your valuation is too high.
Consumers aren’t going to want it.
Hardware is too hard.
You should measure steps.
Fitbit is going to kill you.
You can’t build a marketing engine.
You can’t raise enough money.
You need a real CEO.
Google is going to kill you.
You can’t be a subscription.
You can’t build a brand.
You can’t do consumer in Boston.
Your valuation is too high.
You shouldn’t make accessories.
You shouldn’t make apparel.
Lululemon is going to kill you.
You can’t predict Covid.
Stay in your niche.
You are going to run out of money.
You can’t build a health platform.
Amazon is going to kill you.
You can’t measure blood pressure.
You can’t get medical approvals.
The market is too small.
You don’t understand AI.
The market is too competitive.
It won’t work internationally.
The supply chain is too complicated.
You can’t build an AI.
You can’t raise enough money.
It’s too competitive.
Healthcare isn’t going to want it.
…
Just keep going ✌️
ANNOUNCING OUR FIRST GUEST FOR THE FIRST TECH LATE-NIGHT SHOW.
we had to go big...
THE SCI-FI HARDWARE GOAT @SebastianThrun 🤖
wednesday 3.25 - 8pm (PT)
live on twitch. youtube. X.
interactive. chaotic. fun.
something silicon valley has never seen before.
we're opening 15 in-person spots.
register below ↓
get a seat or a livestream reminder.
We’re giving $1000 to someone to post videos using Odysser.
We believe if one video can change your entire life, we want to help you make that video.
How to win?
1) sign up to Odysser and
2) post 15 videos using/assisted with Odysser
You get free credits so participation won’t cost you anything.
You can join now in our discord community
discord.gg/rcvnqn9E
80K Followers 47K Followingfounder, cyphr vc and previously k2 global. 240M+ prev invested in startups. former lots of things, including journalist, teacher, lawyer, pm, and more.
1.0M Followers 571K FollowingAuthor of The Light in the Heart | Bestselling Writer | Books Amazon: https://t.co/JME330yChV | Positivity, Inspiration, Motivation, Life | All glory be to God
6 Followers 543 FollowingLife doesn’t need to be perfect, only genuine and extraordinary.
My charm comes from the confidence that blooms in silence; gentleness is in my nature, while al
209 Followers 3K FollowingWe are here to pave your path towards financial freedom via the guidance of our multi-millionaire professors. We present to you The Real World.
2.7M Followers 816 FollowingCo-founder & CEO at @Coinbase. Creating more economic freedom in the world. ENS: barmstrong.eth Co-founder @researchhub @newlimit
722K Followers 120 Following#1 NYT Bestselling Author: The 48 Laws of Power, The Art of Seduction, The 33 Strategies of War, The 50th Law, Mastery, The Laws of Human Nature, The Daily Laws
804K Followers 323 FollowingTogether with the AI community, we are pushing the boundaries of what’s possible through open science to create a more connected world.
255K Followers 178 FollowingCo-founder of Thinking Machines Lab @thinkymachines; Ex-VP, AI Safety & robotics, applied research @OpenAI; Author of Lil'Log
459K Followers 1K FollowingML/AI research engineer. Ex stats professor.
Author of "Build a Large Language Model From Scratch" (https://t.co/O8LAAMRzzW) & reasoning (https://t.co/5TueQKx2Fk)